love da book, but then again, i love every warrior cat book. just reading the des makes me eager. cant wait for it to be off of hold and in my hands!

This book is awesome!! I love ALL warriors books- I am a total fan- but this one is of my favorite. It was really sad that Gray Wing died right after he finally found somewhere where he ACTUALLY belonged. Not that the rest of his life was bad or anything. It was actually a much better life than many other warriors characters’. I sort of like it when Gray Wing dies (not that I’m evil or anything) even though he’s pretty much my fave character in dawn of the clans. It’s so sweet and sad!! I like it when warriors makes me cry because it’s always so sweet and makes me smile even while I cry. It’s so awesome how Gray Wing and the kits name the clans and then Turtle Tail comes to get Gray Wing!! - Rosefeather of ThunderClan

The overall book was good, and the ending very sad, but the ending was horrible. They didn't even defeat slash! Also, they to fill up the gap between dawn of the clans and prophecys begin, instead of writing after vision of shadows.

Spoiler Warning!
I loved this book! It's so beautiful and well written. All of Erin Hunters' books are! It's so sad when Gray Wing dies though. I think he was my favorite character in the Dawn of the Clans series. I am glad he found Slate, became a brother to Clear Sky again, had kits of his own, got to see his mother again, gave Fern Leaf a home, saved Star Flower and her kits, raised Thunder, Owl Eyes, Sparrow Fur, and Pebble Eyes, known much love from Turtle Tail and all of his Clanmates, and that he is still following the Sun Trail, the prophecy Stoneteller told Shaded Moss, Lion's Roar, and all of her Tribemates, to StarClan. I'm glad Thunder is happy, has his own clan, and has Violet Dawn, his true love. I am also very happy that the 'groups' are now clans and that Gray Wing named Clear Sky's group. ThunderClan, RiverClan, WindClan, SkyClan, and ShadowClan; they will live on! I recommend reading this book and all of the rest of Erin Hunters' books! I also recommend reading Moth Flight's Vision. That's what I'm going to do. Well, that's all I got to say. xD
DAWN OF THE CLANS!!!!!!!!!!!!

first time reading warriors but it was so good

this book is sooooooooo good! I love all dawn of the clans books it took me like 2 hours non stop to finnish a book. its so heart breaking when gray wing died he didn't deserve to die when clearsky and thunder saved black ear. I wonder how slate his mate felt when he was dying

This book was amazing and heart-breaking!! I was wondering when the 'groups' would finally become Clans!!!!!! I recommend reading Moth Flight's Vision after this it helps finish the series and is perfect for all of those med-cat lovers!

great book and good ending. also after XxsilverstreamxX are some spoiler I think